Since coming into existence of the ICC guidelines regarding the examination of documents, the main duty of the LC bank consists of determining whether the documents appear on their face to comply with the LC provisions. The obligation to strictly follow the issuer's instructions is a consequence of the credit being an instrument of documentary payment. Furthermore, the banks lack the industry specific knowledge and experience to determine the importance of seemingly minor deviations.
The globally recognized principle of compliance does not allow for equitable considerations. Lord Summer's remark made in the 1927 case of Equitable Trust Company of New York ./. Dawson Partners Ltd, (27 Li.L.Rep. 49) still applies: "there is no room for documents which are almost the same or which will do as well."
The discussions in the United States legal community whether to use strict or substantial compliance are of less practical relevance than the doctrines' names might suggest. In the end the discussion focusses on the acceptable exceptions from strict compliance. These exceptions are typically fraud related. It seems however, that a general doctrinal approach to resolving the issue of allowable discrepancies does and will not exist. Rather, a case by case approach to discrepancies as has been utilized in the past seems most appropriate.
A purely literal comparison of LC provisions and presented documents however is not sufficient. Currently still disputed is in how far to allow the interpretation of documents within the context of the Credit.
Comments
Educational Information
triathlon shoesNice! Now I know what to do, thank you! And as this information is educational so this site has been added to my RSS feed for later browsing. To know more about
marathon training visit: marathontrainingschedule.net
[ <a href="http://www.marathontrainingschedule.net">marathon training</a> ]
Education Links
leading online education : Online Schools is an online education directory that specializes in online degrees, online schools, and distance learning. We help thousands of the best online schools, online colleges, and online universities with the best degrees and distance learning programs.
study in india : Study area for a student comes with many questions. The ideal might provide too much privacy and not allow for easy assistance.
used handicap vans for sale
Education related info
: Cambridge is the oldest English language school in Cambridge, UK. Our
language courses are accredited by the British Council and attract
students from all over the world who come to study English in the
professional and friendly environment of our centres.
englisch lernen cambridge : Language and Activity programmes and English Language Courses in
England at Studio Cambridge language school in Ely, Bishop's
Stortford, Richmond-upon-Thames and Reading.
cursos en irlanda : Cursos de inglés en Cork. Aprende inglés en una ciudad dinámica y trepidante. Atención personalizada, respuesta rápida.
Article 14e and 14 f
I agree with most of the comments. Artcile 14e and 14 f is more specific which was left to imagination in earlier versions.
cvrK
An exbanker, into education now! ( can undertake select syndication)
International finace.
he discussions in the United States legal community whether to use
strict or substantial compliance are of less practical relevance than
the doctrines' names might suggest. In the end the discussion focusses
on the acceptable exceptions from strict compliance. These exceptions
are typically fraud related. It seems however, that a general doctrinal
approach to resolving the issue of allowable discrepancies does and will
not exist. Rather, a case by case approach to discrepancies as has been
utilized in the past seems most appropriate.
regards,
phe9oxis,
http://www.guidebuddha.com
International finace
You can start learning through online colleges by first giving yourselftime to think about what it is you need out of a school. Whether youare interested in obtaining an online degree or online certificate, theresources are out there and available to you. However, you must bewilling to do some searching. regards, phe9oxis, http://www.guidebuddha.com
The Teaching Company: The Future of Higher Education?
Many of you (if not most) have probably heard of The Teaching Company.
They make contracts with distinguished professors (many from Ivy
Leagues) to develop audio lecture courses. I've listened to dozens of
these courses over the years and always found them absolutely excellent.
Indeed, I've learned more from some of these courses than I ever did in
college. The professors are always wonderfully articulate and excited
about their course material--it's not hard to see why they have received
so many teaching awards. About a year ago I emailed the teaching
company and asked why they didn't make their courses available for MP3
download. After all, lots of us like to listen to these in our portable
MP3 players and really don't want CDs or tapes. The Teaching Company
said they were looking into it--but, they did more than "look into it."
They now have almost all of their courses available for download at
rates that really surprised me. We're talking $34 for a course instead
of the $200 they were charging for CDs and tapes. What's more, you can
choose to download a single lecture or two at the time to see if it's
something you're interested in. No DRM here. These are straight MP3s
that you can put on as many computers or iPods that you want.
military schools : First in Military Schools. Private, College Preparatory Boys School. Marine Military Academy.
Online Education
This is proven by anyone who
This is proven by anyone who has received L/Cs from different banks for
the same applicant for similar contracts or even parts of larger
multi-million dollar contracts. Each bank places its own interpretation
and procedures on their L/C so that they call for different numbers of
documents, and even call for entirely different documents. farmville cheats
Online High School Diplomas
It used to be that if a person didn’t graduate from high school,
their lives were going to go downhill from there. These days life is a
little more flexible, although it still holds true that to hold a
decent job you need the bare minimum of a high school education.
Luckily, the rise of the digital age has brought about resources to
help those who didn’t graduate obtain a high school diploma online.
Additionally, receiving an online diploma offers teenagers a chance to
obtain a high school education away from the traditional school setting
and to work at a pace that suits them. Whatever the reasons for
getting a high school diploma online, there are certain things everyone
needs to be aware of beforehand.
The importance of a high school diploma cannot be emphasized enough.
There have been numerous studies conducted which show that the average
salaries of individuals with a high school diploma are much greater
than those who do not possess a diploma. Additionally, diploma will
give you a great sense of accomplishment and achievement. Because of
the impact a high school diploma can have on your life, it is important
to fully understand and research the kind of high school degrees the
internet has to offer. By taking the time to properly educate yourself
about online high school diplomas, you will obtain a diploma that not
only helps you financially, but also provides you with a sense of
pride.
When searching for an online high school, it’s important to avoid
being misled by outrageous claims and boldfaced lies. Receiving an
online diploma isn’t a one-night deal; it takes work and dedication
just like receiving a traditional high school diploma would. When
choosing a school to study from, there are usually two options including
public internet schools and private internet schools. Either school
will allow students to acquire an online diploma, but there are certain
advantages and disadvantages to each that you should look into before
deciding on a school that’s right for your needs.
In the case of private internet schools, these institutions are
generally not regulated by the government. Because of this, each school
is allowed to adopt their own rules and regulations throughout the
learning process. Obtaining a high school diploma through a private
school will vary in cost from school to school, but it’s generally very
high because you are responsible for every cost of your education. As
with any school, be sure to check if the particular institution you’re
interested in applying to is accredited by the proper accreditation
boards. Otherwise, your online diploma may not be accepted as proof of a
high school graduate.
With public schools, provided your state allows charter schools it’s
quite possible students will be allowed to enroll in an online public
school free of cost. While charter schools are generally publicly
funded, but have more freedom when it comes to governing organizations.
While achieving an online degrees diploma from a public charter school
is a great deal, they may not be available in all states. To receive
your high school diploma through one of these online institutions, it’s
important to check with your state’s rules regarding charter schools
to ensure you can obtain an online diploma this way.
Whether you want to receive an online university diplomas through a
private or public internet school, it’s important that you do all of
your research beforehand to avoid being burned by the institution. Your
high school diploma will serve as the foundation for furthering your
education and open up new windows of opportunity to you that were
closed before. Obtaining a high school diploma online is a viable and
realistic way to achieve academic success. Provided you are disciplined
and willing to work hard, you will succeed in obtaining an online
diploma.
online certificate programs : If you are looking for a way to boost or start your career we have a complete listing of online certificate programs that are affordable and offered by accredited online colleges.
nursing schools : Online nursing schools with online degrees in all facets of healthcare.
fire science colleges : We offer the top online degree programs for fire science as well as other criminal justice degree fields.
criminal justice university : Guide to online criminal justice schools where you can get an associate\'s or bachelor\'s degree to prepare you for a number of criminal justice
careers.
Online Education : Online Education has become the preferred mode of learning for many all around the world. The choices are plenty when it comes to choosing a career course online. Both students and working professionals can apply for online degrees to enhance their career rospects. This site offers you the advantages of online education and the top institutes that offer these courses.
online auto insurance quotes : Getting to good online auto insurance quotes really just takes a bit of web surfing. You'll want to look up major brands and firms that offer the sort of auto overage you're looking for. But what this assumes of you is that you know what "good auto coverage for you" is. If you don't, you have some work ahead of you.
sejour linguistique angleterre : Sejour linguistique en Angleterre ou aux USA pour assurer une très bonne maîtrise de l'anglais aux collégiens et lycéens et les aider à préparer leur avenir.
Getting an online education
Getting an online education is becoming more popular every day and
there are many great reasons why. Regardless of what field you are in
or interested in, there is almost always a way to advance and improve
your position and going to an online school may be the answer. With the
job market getting tougher, people are looking to going back to college
but may not have the time or resources to do it while still being able
to work their regular job and attend to their families. However, the
birth of online colleges and universities has allowed more
opportunities for busy people to have a chance at getting ahead.
You can start learning through online colleges by first giving yourself
time to think about what it is you need out of a school. Whether you
are interested in obtaining an online degree or online certificate, the
resources are out there and available to you. However, you must be
willing to do some searching.
Catering Jobs : Discover Catering specializes in catering jobs and catering recruitment throughout the UK.
Hospitality Management Schools :Find the top Hospitality management degrees using our guide to online colleges
and universities that specialize in travel and tourism.
Best Online Colleges :-Find the best accredited online degrees in your field of interest and use our exclusive existing and alumni student satisfaction rankings to help you choose a great online college.
Mortgage Refinance Brisban :
Mortgage Refinance Brisban : Home loan services Brisbane is professional team of lending and finance specialists ready to provide financial services, loan advice and lending solutions. The Home loan services Brisbane financial advisors have access to a wide range of lending products and financing solutions from Australian and overseas banks and financial institutions. Home loan services Brisbane are the Brisbane mortgage and finance brokers you can trust for a low interest rate and tailored financial solutions and finance services to loan you the funds you need to live, do business, invest in your future, and enjoy life.
Debt Consolidation Gold Coast : Home Loan Services Gold Coast is professional team of lending and finance specialists ready to provide financial services, loan advice and lending solutions. The Home Loan Services Gold Coast financial advisors have access to a wide range of lending products and financing solutions from Australian and overseas banks and financial institutions.
Standard for Exam.of Docs
Dear admin ! Lord Summer´s sentence is for me a substantial view on docs preparing or examining. I think all concerned parties, i.e. applicant and his bank, the beneficiary and his advising bank should very carefully check the contents of the new L/C, not copying an old one which needed to be amended. I have seen so much L/C showing under 46A three documents (Invoice, B/L and Packing List), 47A stipulating many non-documentary clauses. Now the question is - shall I disregard them as per UCP Art. 14h or creating documents to match them ? Furthermore it should be considered to check the L/C after advising with basic proforma invoice or contract, if the details conform to them. Then the transport -document should be discussed with freight forwarder if all stipulations - beginning in field 44A (place of receipt/ dispatch from) if filled and then E, F and B - can be fulfilled. My recommendation is: if not possible L/C has to be amended to avoid any inconveniences with banks. LC is a payment method - clear and transparent details shoud be a safe harbour to get money. What do You think about this ? Rgds Kurt
standard of examination
the issue to be examined keeping in view UCP. a complying presentation has to be 1. credit compliant 2. rules compliant 3 ISBP compliant, the article 14 e ; 14 f adds to contriversy and loosens the doctrine of strict compliance.
it may be suggested that while opening a bank may exclude 14f of UCP in credit.
views please!
Article 14 (f), UCP 600
Article 14 (f), does not "add to controversy", but clarifies what appears to have been implicit under the old Article 21 of the UCP 500. In point of fact, the sub-article is part of the strength of the current Code.
Document examination
Good article Admin - it is for these reasons that UCP600 clearly leaves the decision as to acceptability of the documents for the purposes of the L/C strictly with the banks.
You also need to take into consideration other risk pressures that are not requirements of the L/C, such as where are the goods being shipped/in which country is the issuing bank? Are the underlying goods subject to price fluctuation between shipment and payment? and also the number one driver in documentary presentations from the nominated banks point of view - "if I let this go, will I still get paid?" - It is still fear of not receiving reimbursement that drives many bank decisions on the acceptability of presented documents.
The Teaching Company said
The Teaching Company
said they were looking into it--but, they did more than "look into it."
They now have almost all of their courses available for download at
rates that really surprised me. We're talking $34 for a course instead
of the $200 they were charging for CDs and tapes. What's more, you can
choose to download a single lecture or two at the time to see if it's
something you're interested in. Electronic Cigarette
Document examination
Peter M,
I Agree whole-heartedly regarding your closing comment. While the documentary credit is theoretically the opening bank's guarantee to the receiving bank that, "if documents are presented in accordance with what we have stipulated in this LC, we will pay you" I have seen that the receiving banks do not necessarily trust the opening banks anymore.
Regards
pame1a
Document examination
Hi,
Kurt made a good point, so many L/Cs now have documentary and non-documentary requirements appearing in 47A instead of 46A. This is because of the abysmal skills amongst bankers in many countries, often where the buyer would be afraid to question the banker as he is seen as an arm of authority for their government. The overall quality of L/Cs these days is very poor and actually interferes with the contractual arrangements between seller and buyer. Often the buyer won't even be aware of what a mess their bank has made of the L/C.
This is proven by anyone who has received L/Cs from different banks for the same applicant for similar contracts or even parts of larger multi-million dollar contracts. Each bank places its own interpretation and procedures on their L/C so that they call for different numbers of documents, and even call for entirely different documents.
This kind of issuing bank incompetence certainly does not engender a like of L/Cs amongst exporters as it makes it harder for them to comply.
Regards,
Bob